BIRTHWISE IN BIRMINGHAM
  • Home
  • About Us
    • About Dalia >
      • Dalia Testimonials
    • About Susan
    • About Anjanette
    • About Renee
    • About Yanick
    • About Blakely
  • Services
    • Open House
    • Birth Doulas >
      • The evidence for doulas
      • On-Call doulas
    • A La Carte Childbirth Classes >
      • Birth Prep Essentials
      • Instinctive Birth
      • Navigating your Hospital Birth Part I
      • Navigating Your Hospital Birth Part II
      • Comprehensive Comfort Measures
      • Getting Off to the Breast Start
      • Welcome to Parenting!
      • Soothe & Sleep
      • Childbirth Class Testimonials
    • Private Childbirth Class
    • Birth Prep Coaching
    • StrongParent Virtual Group
    • Breastfeeding Services
    • Massage
    • Birth Pool Rental
    • Birth Doula Workshop
  • Contact Us
    • Sign up for our Email List
    • Register for "A La Carte" classes
    • Open House RSVP
  • Gift Certificates
  • Blog
    • Birth Memoirs
  • Forms and Printouts
  • Dalia's Soap Box

Hospital C-section rates

5/16/2017

3 Comments

 
A 2017 article in Medscape suggested it's important for you to know hospital c-section rates as you choose where to have your baby.
Here's a quote from the article, and you can go here to read the whole thing:
'Cesarean delivery rates can vary widely even among hospitals located near one another. ...
"This variation is a critical point in our analysis because there is a big, important take-away for moms. You cannot afford not to know the track record of the hospital where you're delivering," Doris Peter, PhD, director, Consumer Reports Health Ratings Center, said in a statement.'

So we have pulled together some rates for area hospitals to help you find the best place for your birth.

First: here is a chart of total c-section rates for Birmingham hospitals in 2013. This information comes from the web site www.CesareanRates.com. Note that the bars with the black outline are for hospitals where MANY babies are born each year, over 3000. Note too that Cooper Green stopped doing births in 2011, so this rate is old. I include it here because Cooper Green, when women had babies there, was serving people with the LEAST prenatal care and health coverage, and still had a lower section rate than hospitals serving large populations. So when people say that the reason for high section rates is the health of the people giving birth at their hospital, or because the women they serve don't get prenatal care, the rate from Cooper Green shows this is not a good explanation.

Picture
UPDATED: 11/15/2020
Next, here is a chart showing section rates in 2017. This information comes from the Alabama 2017 Vital Statistic Report. Please pay attention to the change at Princeton Hospital. This is important because it shows how c-section rates can change drastically when there is a change in practice norms. Dr. Cooper started working at Princeton in 2013; look what happened when she started putting women at the center of decision making about their own care, and hired Certified Nurse Midwives to provide prenatal care and attend births for low-risk birth-givers!!!
Picture
The c-section rate at Brookwood Hospital in 2013 was 43.8% (according to www.CesareanRates.com). But they too, are working hard to reduce their section rates. Here is what they have accomplished, as communicated to me by Brookwood Hospital administration in May of 2017. And I quote:
  • “Brookwood Baptist Medical Center is committed to continual improvement in lowering C-section rates. Our interdisciplinary team of obstetricians and nurses work collaboratively on strategies to support vaginal birth. When comparing our 2016 data to the 2013 published data we demonstrated a 7.39% reduction in our total C-section rate and a 9.8% reduction in our primary rate. We are very proud that 78.9% of our mothers, who attempted a vaginal birth after a previous C-section were successful. Helping our mothers who desire to achieve a successful vaginal birth is at the heart of our mission.”
Indeed, their rate was 35.6% in 2017.
The rate they quote for successful vaginal births after c-sections (VBAC) is comparable to what the research suggests is possible (70-80%). Although the proportion of people who are offered the opportunity to labor after a previous c-section is less than 15%..

Below is the VBAC rate for each hospital in 2017, again, from the Alabama 2017 Vital Statistics Report
Picture
Those are all the numbers I have to share with you. Talk to your doula about how to avoid a c-section when it isn't necessary. And choose your hospital and medical professionals with CARE!

When a c-section is necessary, here are some photos of family friendly practices!!
3 Comments
buy an essay cheap link
5/28/2017 12:09:32 am

I see that most Mothers would have a Cesarean surgery than normal ones. I don't really blame them, since it's practically easier in their case. It's hard to give birth to a large baby, and most of the times a woman can't handle the stress and pain. It's better to have a cesarean operation, than to risk it.

Reply
informed women
3/22/2018 01:38:49 pm

Its unfortunate that many (like the comment above) generalize women and decide for them that "a woman can't handle the stress," leading to increase C/S rates. It may be "hard" to give birth to a large baby, but women CAN handle it. Your body was made and designed to handle it. It's time to start empowering the laboring mother rather than discouraging her. What is actually "hard" is the recovery of a C/S and the hindrance to the beautiful and needed bond between mother and baby it creates.

Reply
Brandi Mularski
2/9/2021 10:54:05 am

Thank you so much for the information! Very helpful.

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Archives

    May 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    May 2018
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    December 2016
    March 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015

    Categories

    All
    Birth
    Birth Biography
    Birth Doula
    Birth Memoir
    Birth Partner
    Birth Plan
    Birth Story
    Birth Team
    Brookwood
    Cesarean Birth
    Cesarean Section
    Childbirth Class
    Choosing Your Care Provider
    Comfort Measures
    C-section
    Dads And Doulas
    Dalia
    Doula
    Dr. Cooper
    Earthy Birthy Fair
    Evidence Based Care
    Expo
    Fitness
    Heather
    Hospital Birth
    IChooseB
    IDecideHow
    Kaleigh
    Microaggressions
    Monogram Maternity
    Postpartum
    Pregnancy
    Princeton
    Racism
    Rights
    Simon Williamson
    St. Vincent's
    UAB
    VBA3C
    VBAC

    RSS Feed